Easy Soft Christmas Peppermints

If you’re craving a nostalgic holiday treat that melts in your mouth and fills the room with the comforting scent of peppermint, these Soft Christmas Peppermints—also known as Old-Fashioned Butter Mints—are exactly what you need. Whether you remember them from your grandmother’s candy dish or you’re simply searching for a homemade candy that’s as festive as it is easy to make, this recipe is sure to win you over. With their creamy texture, delicate sweetness, and cheerful red and white swirls, they’re a delightful addition to any Christmas dessert spread.

These charming little mints are a classic that never goes out of style, and for good reason. They’re soft, smooth, and gently flavored with peppermint, making them perfect for guests of all ages. Unlike store-bought versions, homemade butter mints are fresher, softer, and far more flavorful. And the best part? They require no baking, only a few simple ingredients, and a little bit of time and patience. The process is straightforward, relaxing, and even fun—ideal for making with kids or gifting to friends and neighbors.

If you love making homemade holiday candy but want something that feels a little different than fudge or brittle, you’ll be surprised at how satisfying these Soft Christmas Peppermints are to create and enjoy. Let’s dive into exactly how to make these delightful treats and why they deserve a permanent place in your holiday recipe rotation.

Save

Why You’ll Love These Old-Fashioned Butter Mints

There are so many reasons to fall in love with Old-Fashioned Butter Mints. To begin with, they offer that creamy, melt-away texture that’s completely different from typical hard mints. They’re sweet without being overpowering, and the hint of peppermint is refreshing yet gentle—never too sharp. That’s what makes them ideal after a heavy holiday meal or as a little pick-me-up throughout the day.

Another reason they’re so popular is their versatility. While we’re making them in classic red and white today, you can easily change up the colors to match any theme—think pastel shades for Easter, green for St. Patrick’s Day, or blue and white for winter celebrations. You can also adjust the peppermint extract to taste or even try other extracts like vanilla or almond for a creative twist.

Plus, the ingredients are simple and likely already in your pantry. No candy thermometer, special molds, or hard-to-find items required. And because the candy air-dries instead of baking, it’s a wonderfully hands-off recipe once you’ve shaped the dough.

These butter mints are a fantastic addition to cookie platters, party favor bags, or just for keeping in a decorative jar on the counter. And if you enjoy making edible gifts, they pair beautifully with Christmas Sugar Cookie Dip or Christmas Jam for a thoughtful and delicious holiday bundle.

Ingredients for Soft Christmas Peppermints

To make these homemade Soft Christmas Peppermints, you’ll only need a few basic ingredients:

• ½ cup butter – Make sure it’s at room temperature for easier mixing. Unsalted is best for flavor control.
• 4 cups powdered sugar – Also called confectioners’ sugar, this is the main dry ingredient that gives the mints their sweetness and structure.
• 2 tablespoons heavy whipping cream – Adds richness and creates a creamy texture.
• ¼ teaspoon peppermint extract – Feel free to adjust slightly depending on your preferred level of minty flavor.
• Red food coloring or gel – Used to color a portion of the dough for the signature peppermint twist.

Optionally, have extra powdered sugar on hand for dusting your surface or adjusting the dough consistency if needed. Because these ingredients are so common, it’s easy to whip up a batch on a whim—perfect for spontaneous holiday cheer!

Save

How to Make Soft Christmas Peppermints Step-by-Step

Start by preparing your workspace. Lay down parchment paper, wax paper, or a silicone baking mat on a flat surface where you’ll be working the dough and letting the mints dry. It’s also helpful to have extra powdered sugar nearby in case the dough becomes too sticky to handle.

In a large mixing bowl, add your softened butter. Use a hand or stand mixer to beat the butter until it becomes light and fluffy. This step ensures that your base will be soft and well-blended.

Next, gradually add in the powdered sugar, heavy cream, and peppermint extract. Start mixing slowly to prevent the sugar from puffing up into the air, then increase the speed until the mixture comes together in a thick dough. You’re looking for a firm consistency that’s not crumbly but holds its shape well—like a soft playdough.

Once your dough is ready, divide it into two sections. Set aside about one-fourth of the dough and add red food coloring to this portion. Knead it gently until the color is evenly distributed. Leave the remaining three-fourths white. If the dough feels too sticky at any point, sprinkle on a bit more powdered sugar.

Now comes the fun part. Take small amounts of each color and roll them into ropes. Make the white rope slightly thicker and the red one a little thinner. Place the two ropes side by side and gently twist them together to create a classic peppermint swirl. Once twisted, roll the rope between your palms to smooth out the shape.

Let the twisted ropes rest on your prepared surface. After an hour or two, when they’re less sticky but not yet fully hardened, use a sharp knife or pizza cutter to slice them into small bite-sized pieces. Let the mints sit out for a full 24 hours to finish drying and hardening.

Once dry, your homemade butter mints are ready to enjoy!

Save

Kitchen Equipment You’ll Need for Butter Mints

Making Old-Fashioned Butter Mints doesn’t require any special equipment, but having the right tools on hand makes the process much smoother:

• Mixing bowl (preferably large)
• Hand or stand mixer
• Measuring cups and spoons
• Silicone spatula or spoon
• Parchment or wax paper
• Pizza cutter or sharp knife
• Optional: gloves for handling food coloring

Everything listed is commonly found in most kitchens, making this a great beginner-friendly holiday recipe.

Tips for Perfect Old-Fashioned Butter Mints

To ensure success with your Soft Christmas Peppermints, here are some tips and tricks:

• Soften your butter completely before mixing. Cold butter won’t blend smoothly with the sugar and cream.
• Add powdered sugar gradually to avoid a mess and help achieve the right consistency.
• Don’t overdo the extract—peppermint is strong, and a little goes a long way.
• Work in small batches when rolling and twisting to keep the dough pliable.
• Let the mints dry properly for at least 24 hours for the best texture.

If you’re looking to build a festive candy plate, these mints pair wonderfully with Candy Cane Cookies or even Espresso Shortbread Cookies for a balance of sweet and bold.

Serving and Presentation Ideas for Christmas Peppermints

Presentation makes all the difference, especially during the holidays. Consider displaying your Soft Christmas Peppermints in a clear glass jar tied with a ribbon, or place them in small tins lined with tissue paper for easy gifting.

You can also serve them:

• In cupcake liners on a dessert tray
• Wrapped in mini cellophane bags with gift tags
• As table favors at Christmas dinner
• In a holiday candy buffet alongside Christmas Morning Chai Latte

Their cheerful colors and vintage look make them a charming addition to any festive display.

Common Mistakes to Avoid with Butter Mints

Though the recipe is simple, avoid these common pitfalls:

• Using cold butter, which prevents proper mixing.
• Adding too much food coloring, which can make the dough sticky or stain your hands.
• Overmixing, which might soften the dough too much.
• Skipping the drying time, resulting in sticky or overly soft mints.

Take your time and follow each step carefully to achieve that perfect melt-in-your-mouth texture.

Fun Variations on This Soft Christmas Peppermints Candy Recipe

These butter mints are endlessly customizable. Try some of these ideas to change things up:

• Switch up the colors for other holidays—think pink and white for Valentine’s Day or green for St. Patrick’s Day.
• Use different extracts like vanilla, almond, or lemon for a new flavor profile.
• Add sprinkles or edible glitter to the twisted ropes before drying for extra sparkle.
• Shape into balls or squares instead of twisting for a simpler style.

If you’re in the mood to experiment with other nostalgic treats, try these Cherry Chocolate Chip Cookies or Old-Fashioned Fruitcake Cookies.

How to Store Homemade Butter Mints Properly

Proper storage keeps your Soft Christmas Peppermints fresh and flavorful:

• Once dry, store them in an airtight container at room temperature.
• No refrigeration needed, though it won’t hurt if you prefer a firmer texture.
• Separate layers with parchment to prevent sticking.
• Shelf life is about two weeks, though they’re often gone long before that.

They also ship well if you want to mail them to loved ones during the holidays.

Perfect Pairings for Soft Christmas Peppermints

These Soft Christmas Peppermints mints are perfect after dinner, but they also shine when paired with:

• A cup of hot cocoa or Salted Caramel Hot Chocolate
• Shortbread cookies or holiday biscotti
• A fruit platter for contrast
• Chocolate bark or Peppermint Pie for a themed dessert board

They also make a lovely palate cleanser between rich desserts or as a refreshing treat during gift opening.

FAQs About Soft Christmas Peppermints

Can I freeze the mints?
It’s best to avoid freezing as it can change the texture, but they do store well in airtight containers.

How strong is the peppermint flavor?
Very mild. You can increase or decrease to taste using the extract.

Can I use liquid food coloring instead of gel?
Yes, but use it sparingly to avoid changing the dough consistency.

What if my dough is too sticky?
Just add a bit more powdered sugar and mix until it firms up.

Do I have to let them dry for 24 hours?
For the best texture, yes. However, you can eat them sooner—they’ll just be softer.

Final Thoughts on Soft Christmas Peppermints

These Soft Christmas Peppermints, also known as Old-Fashioned Butter Mints, are the perfect homemade holiday candy. They’re simple to make, easy to customize, and absolutely melt-in-your-mouth delicious. Whether you’re making them for a festive party, a homemade gift, or just a fun afternoon in the kitchen, they’re sure to bring smiles and sweet holiday cheer.

If you enjoyed this Soft Christmas Peppermints recipe, don’t forget to share it with your friends and family, and be sure to subscribe to our blog for more festive treats, homemade gifts, and creative holiday ideas.

Print